出口产品质量与工薪差距——基于中国行业层面数据的研究

贵州财经大学学报 ›› 2020 ›› Issue (02): 28-38.

出口产品质量与工薪差距——基于中国行业层面数据的研究

刘钧霆¹, 王子睿¹, 佟继英^1,2

1. 辽宁大学, 辽宁沈阳 110036;
2. 唐山学院, 河北唐山 063000

收稿日期:2019-06-19 出版日期:2020-03-15 发布日期:2020-03-24
作者简介:刘钧霆(1972-),男,辽宁大连人,博士,教授,博士生导师,研究方向为国际经济问题;王子睿(1994-),男,河南郑州人,博士研究生,研究方向为国际经济问题;佟继英(1975-),女,河北唐山人,副教授,辽宁大学博士研究生,研究方向为国际经济问题。
基金资助:
2019年度国家社会科学基金项目"产业政策和WTO规则兼容性研究"（19BJL089）；辽宁省2017年度社科规划基金重点项目"辽宁省改善营商环境与提升开放型经济水平互动研究"（L17AJY008）；2019年度辽宁省经济社会发展研究课题"促进辽宁生产性服务业发展的营商因素研究"（2019lslktyb-015）。

Export product quality and wage gap-research based on industry-level data in China

LIU Jun-ting¹, WANG Zi-rui¹, TONG Ji-ying^1,2

1. Liaoning University, Shenyang, Liaoning 110036, China;
2. Tangshan College, Tangshan, Hebei 063000, China

Received:2019-06-19 Online:2020-03-15 Published:2020-03-24

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 使用CEPII中BACI-HS02微观贸易数据库，运用"质量-调整"价格法测算了中国行业层面的出口产品质量。并选取2007~2016年制造业22个细分行业的相关数据，借助OLS法以及差分GMM模型，从理论和实证两方面分析了出口产品质量对工薪差距的影响。理论分析表明，出口产品质量提升对工薪差距的影响具有不确定性。实证研究发现，中国出口产品质量提升将通过技能溢价机制和利润分享机制扩大工薪差距，劳动生产率和外商直接投资对扩大工薪差距也具有显著影响。技术进步和外商直接投资对出口质量对工薪差距的影响具有明显的调节效应，其中技术进步具有正向调节效应，外商直接投资则具有负向调节效应。稳健性检验表明了估计结果的可靠性。为缩小工薪差距，政府应加大对低技能劳动力群体的人力资本投资，同时企业应增加对低技能劳动力的技能培训力度，提高低技能劳动力的技能水平。

关键词: 出口产品质量, 工薪差距, 调节效应

Abstract: This paper uses the micro-trade database of BACI-HS02 in CEPII, and uses the "quality-adjustment" price method to measure the quality of export products at the Chinese industry level. The relevant data of 22 sub-sectors in manufacturing industry from 2007 to 2016 were selected. With the OLS method and the differential GMM model, the impact of export product quality on wage gap was analyzed from both theoretical and empirical aspects. Theoretical analysis shows that the impact of the quality of export products on the wage gap is uncertain. The empirical study found that the improvement of China's export product quality will expand the wage gap through the skill premium mechanism and profit sharing mechanism. Labor productivity and foreign direct investment also have a significant impact on the expansion of wage gap. Technological progress and foreign direct investment have obvious adjustment effects on the impact of export quality on wage gap. Among them, technological progress has a positive adjustment effect, while foreign direct investment has a negative adjustment effect. The robustness test indicates the reliability of the estimation results. In order to narrow the wage gap, the government should increase investment in human capital for low-skilled labor groups. At the same time, enterprises should increase the skills training for low-skilled labor and improve the skill level of low-skilled labor.

Key words: Export product quality, wage gap, adjustment effect

中图分类号:

F769.2

刘钧霆, 王子睿, 佟继英. 出口产品质量与工薪差距——基于中国行业层面数据的研究[J]. 贵州财经大学学报, 2020(02): 28-38.

LIU Jun-ting, WANG Zi-rui, TONG Ji-ying. Export product quality and wage gap-research based on industry-level data in China[J]. Journal of Guizhou University of Finance and Economics, 2020(02): 28-38.

参考文献

[1] 刘灿雷,王永进,李宏兵.出口产品质量分化与工资不平等-来自中国制造业的经验证据[J].财贸经济,2018(01).
[2] Leamer,E. In Search of Stolper-Samuelson Linkages between International Trade and Lower Wages.in S.M.Collins,ed.,Imports,Exports,and the American Worker[M].Washington,D.C.:Brookings Institution Press,1998.
[3] Krugman,P.Technology,Trade and Factor Prices[J].Journal of International Economics,2000,50(1).
[4] Helpman,E.General Purpose Technologies and Economic Growth[M]. Cambridge,MA:MIT Press,1998.
[5] Zhu.S.C..Trade.Product Cycles and Inequality within and between Countries.Canadian Journal of Economics,2004.
[6] Head K., Ries J.. Increasing Returns versus National Product Differentiation as an Explanation for the Pattern of US-Canada Trade[J]. American Economic Review, 2001,91(4).
[7] Baumgarten,D.Exporters and the Rise in Wage Inequality:Evidence from German Linked Employer-Employee Data[J].Journal of International Economics,2013,90.
[8] Xu,B,W.Li.Trade,Technology,and China's Rising Skill Demand[J].Economics of Transition,2008,16(1).
[9] Anwar,S. and Sun,S.Trade Liberalization,Market Competition and Wage Inequality in China's Manufacturing Sector[J].Economic Modelling,2012,29(04).
[10] 邵敏,刘重力.出口贸易、技术进步的偏向性与我国工资不平等[J].经济评论,2010(04).
[11] 王中华,梁俊伟.国际服务外包、就业与工薪差距:基于中国工业行业数据的实证分析[J].经济经纬,2012(01).
[12] Han,J.; Liu,R. and Zhang,J.Globalization and Wage Inequality:Evidence from Urban China[J]. Journal of International Economics,2012,87(2).
[13] 王怀民.加工贸易与工薪差距:基于我国的实证研究[J].经济经纬,2014(03).
[14] 陈波,贺超群.出口与工资差距:基于我国工业企业的理论与实证分析[J].管理世界,2013(08).
[15] 杜威剑,李梦洁.出口会扩大企业内工资差距吗——基于市场进入视角的微观解释[J].财贸研究,2017(02).
[16] Verhoogen,E. A.Trade,Quality Upgrading,and Wage Inequality in the Mexican Manufacturing Sector[J]. Quarterly Journal of Economics,Vol. 123,No. 2,2008.
[17] Brambilla,I.,Lederman,D.,& Porto,G.,Exports,Export Destinations,and Skills[J]. American Economic Review,Vol. 102,No. 7,2012.
[18] Brambilla,I.,& Porto,G.,High-income Export Destinations,Quality and Wages. Journal of International Economics,Vol. 98,No. 2,2016.
[19] Yeaple,S.R.A Simple Model of Firm Heterogeneity,International Trade,and Wages[J]. Journal of international Economics,Vol. 65,No. 1,2005.
[20] Bustos P.Trade Liberalization,Exports,and Technology Upgrading:Evidence on the Impact of MERCOSUR on Argentinian Firms[J]. American Economic Review,Vol. 101,No. 1,2011.
[21] Helpman E.Itskhoki O.,Muendler M. A. & Redding,S.,Trade and Inequality:from Theory To Estimation[J]. Review of Economic Studies,Vol. 84,No. 1,2017.
[22] Feenstra,R.C.G.Hanson. Global Production Sharing and Rising Inequality:A Survey of Trade and Wages[J].NBER WorkingPaper,2001.
[23] Davis,D. R.& Harrigan,J.,Good Jobs,Bad Jobs,and Trade Liberalization[J]. Journal of International Economics,Vol. 84,No. 1,2011.
[24] Helpman E.Itskhoki O. & Redding S.Inequality and Unemployment In a Global Economy[J]. Econometrica,Vol. 78,No. 4,2010.
[25] Khandelwal,A. K.Schott,P. K.,& Wei,S. J.Trade Liberalization and Embedded Institutional Reform:Evidence from Chinese Exporters[J]. American Economic Review,Vol. 103,No. 6,2013.
[26] Anderson J. E.van Wincoop E.Trade Costs[J]. Journal of Economic Literature, 2004, 42(3).20.Basco,S. and Mestieri,M.Heterogeneous Trade Costs and Wage Inequality:A Model of Two Globalizations[J].Journal of International Economics,2013.
[27] Fan,H.,Li Y.,& Yeaple,Y.Trade Liberalization,Quality and Export Prices[J]. Review of Economics and Statistics,Vol. 97,No. 5,2015.
[28] 刘洪铎,陈和,李文宇.产业集聚对出口产品质量的影响效应研究-基于中国省际面板数据的实证分析[J].当代经济研究,2016(07).
[29] 罗知,赵奇伟.为什么中国高投资与低劳动收入占比并存?——劳动生产率与工资增速差距的视角[J].世界经济文汇,2013(06).
[30] 雷钦礼,徐家春.技术进步偏向、要素配置偏向与我国TFP的增长[J].统计研究,2015(08).
[31] 周昕.全球价值链分工如何影响高技术劳动力相对工资?——基于我国制造业部门的研究[J].财经论丛,2017,218(04).