社会基本医疗保险对农民工就业流动的影响研究——基于居民医保和职工医保比较的视角

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 农民工的就业流动是缩小城乡差距、实现共同富裕的重要途径。基于2017年全国流动人口动态监测调查数据，研究社会基本医疗保险对农民工就业流动的影响。研究发现：与职工医保相比，居民医保减少了农民工的流动时间；居民医保促进了流动3次以上的概率；与居民医保相比，职工医保促进了农民工的跨市、跨县流动。异质性结果表明，居民医保弱化了老一代农民工跨市和跨县流动，而职工医保促进了新一代农民工的跨市流动；在户籍地参加居民医保或职工医保都会对农民工就业流动产生"回拉"效果。因此，为了促进农民工就业流动以及削弱流动过程中社会基本医疗保险的牵制作用，应创造条件鼓励更多的农民工参加职工医保；提高医疗保险的统筹层次，减少医疗保险的转移接续障碍。

关键词: 农民工, 居民医保, 职工医保, 就业流动

Abstract: The employment flow of migrant workers is an important way to narrow the gap between urban and rural areas and achieve common prosperity. Based on the dynamic monitoring survey data of the national floating population in 2017, the impact of social basic medical insurance on the employment flow of migrant workers was studied. The study found that compared with the medical insurance for employees, the resident medical insurance reduced the migrant workers' flow time; Residents' medical insurance promotes the probability of more than three times of mobility; Compared with the resident medical insurance, the employee medical insurance promotes the cross-city and cross-county flow of migrant workers. The heterogeneity results show that the resident medical insurance weakens the cross-city and cross-county flow of the old generation of migrant workers, while the employee medical insurance promotes the cross-city flow of the new generation of migrant workers; Participating in residents' medical insurance or workers' medical insurance in registered residence will have a "pull back" effect on migrant workers' employment mobility. Therefore, in order to promote the employment flow of migrant workers and weaken the restraining role of social basic medical insurance in the process of migration, we should create conditions to encourage more migrant workers to participate in employee medical insurance; Improve the overall level of medical insurance and reduce the transfer and continuity barriers of medical insurance.

Key words: migrant workers, resident basic medical insurance, employee basic health insurance, employment flow

中图分类号:

王翠琴, 林潇. 社会基本医疗保险对农民工就业流动的影响研究——基于居民医保和职工医保比较的视角[J]. 贵州财经大学学报, 2023(02): 83-92.

WANG Cui-qin, LIN Xiao. Research on the influence of social basic medical insurance on migrant workers' employment flow-Based on the perspective of comparison between resident medical insurance and employee medical insurance[J]. Journal of Guizhou University of Finance and Economics, 2023(02): 83-92.

参考文献

[1] 李珍.新时代:中国社会保障发展的新蓝图[J].社会保障研究,2017(6):3~10.
[2] 王延中,龙玉其,江翠萍,徐强.中国社会保障收入再分配效应研究——以社会保险为例[J].经济研究,2016(2):4~15;41.
[3] 王秀峰,吴华章,甘戈.卫生健康在共同富裕中的地位作用与主要任务[J].卫生经济研究,2022(2):1~5;9.
[4] 周强,张全红,蔡智全.农村医疗保险制度对居民收入差距的影响[J].中南财经政法大学学报,2021(4):105~118.
[5] 徐姗,邓羽,王开泳.中国流动人口的省际迁移模式、集疏格局与市民化路径[J].地理科学,2016(11):1637~1642.
[6] 李珍.迈向高质量全民统一覆盖的医疗保险制度[J].中国卫生政策研究,2020(1):2~8.
[7] 任辉,任巧巧.农民工医疗保险需求强度与参保行为:对背离现象的解释[J].学习与实践,2020(3):61~75.
[8] 周云波,黄云.基本医疗保险制度能否改善农民工的相对不平等[J].财经科学,2021(10):84~97.
[9] Tian Y H, Chen Y X, Zhou M, et al. Institutional Design and Incentives for Migrant Workers to Participate in Social Insurance in China:Evidence From a Policy Experiment in Chengdu City[J]. Frontiers in Public Health,2021,9.
[10] 汪润泉,赵广川,刘玉萍.农民工跨城市流动就业的工资溢价效应——对农民工频繁流动的一个解释[J].农业技术经济,2021(7):131~144.
[11] Lee S, Torm N. Social Security and Firm Performance:The Case of Vietnamese SMEs[J]. International Labour Review, 2017(2):185~212.
[12] Lluis S, Abraham J. The Wage-Health Insurance Trade-off and Worker Selection:Evidence From the Medical Expenditure Panel Survey 1997 to 2006[J]. Industrial Relations A Journal of Economy & Society, 2013(2):541~581.
[13] 曾明星,吴瑞君,张善余.中国人口再分布新形势及其社会经济效应研究——基于"六普"数据的分析[J].人口学刊,2013(5):15~25.
[14] 吴方卫,康姣姣.农民工流向选择和区域流动变化研究——基于河南省农民工流向的经验研究[J].农业技术经济,2019(12):43~55.
[15] 何筠,张嘉佳.新生代农民工就业稳定性的影响因素及代际差异研究[J].江西社会科学,2021(2):218~227;256.
[16] Stroupe K T, Kniesner K T J J. Chronic Illness and Health Insurance-Related Job Lock[J]. Journal of Policy Analysis & Management, 2001(3):525;44.
[17] 刘丽丽.就业稳定性与农民工消费:理论解释与经验证据[J].消费经济,2021(1):50~58.
[18] 石智雷.有多少农民工实现了职业上升——人力资本、行业分割与农民工职业垂直流动[J].人口与经济,2017(6):90~104.
[19] Parsons, D O. Specific Human Capital:An Application to Quit Rates and Layoff Rates. Journal of Political Economy, 1972,80(6):1120~1143.
[20] 章元,陆铭.社会网络是否有助于提高农民工的工资水平?[J].管理世界,2009(3):45~54.
[21] 严善平.中国大城市劳动力市场的结构转型——对2003年、2009年上海就业调查的实证分析[J].管理世界,2011(9):53~62;187.
[22] 朱静.社会结构中流动人口的阶层地位分析[J].中州学刊,2010(5):118~122.
[23] 田明.进城农民工的高流动性及其解释[J].清华大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2013(5):69~80;160.
[24] 田北海,雷华,佘洪毅,等.人力资本与社会资本孰重孰轻:对农民工职业流动影响因素的再探讨——基于地位结构观与网络结构观的综合视角[J].中国农村观察,2013(1):34~47;91.
[25] 刘莹莹,梁栩凌,张一名.新生代农民工人力资本对其就业质量的影响[J].调研世界,2018(12):30;35.
[26] 蔡昉,都阳,王美艳.户籍制度与劳动力市场保护[J].经济研究,2001(12):41~49;91.
[27] 孙文凯,白重恩,谢沛初.户籍制度改革对中国农村劳动力流动的影响[J].经济研究,2011(1):28~41.
[28] Allegretto S, Dube A, Reich M, et al. Credible Research Designs for Minimum Wage Studies[J]. ILR Review, 2017(3):559~592.
[29] 杨正雄,张世伟.最低工资对农民工非正规就业和工资的影响[J].农业经济问题,2020(9):40~54.
[30] Nyland C, Smyth R, Zhu C J. What Determines the Extent to which Employers will Comply with their Social Security Obligations? Evidence from Chinese Firm-level Data[J]. Social Policy & Administration, 2006(2):196~214.
[31] 于新亮,申宇鹏,李红波.新农保非携带性对农村劳动力流动的锁定效应——兼论对新农合锁定效应的替代[J].中国农村观察,2019(6):109~126.
[32] Inas Rashad E S. Employer-provided Health Insurance and the Incidence of Job Lock:a Literature Review and Empirical Test[J]. Expert Review of Pharmacoeconomics & Outcomes Research, 2008(6):583;91.
[33] Madrian B C. Employment-Based Health Insurance and Job Mobility:Is there Evidence of Job-Lock?[J]. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1994(1):27~54.
[34] Thomas C, Buchmueller, et al. The Effects of Employer-Provided Health Insurance on Worker Mobility[J]. Industrial and Labor Relations Review, 1996,49(3):439~455.
[35] Gilleskie D, Lutz B. The Impact of Employer-Provided Health Insurance on Dynamic Employment Transitions[J]. The Journal of Human Resources, 2002(1):129~162.
[36] Monheit A C, Cooper P F. Health Insurance and Job Mobility:Theory and Evidence[J]. Industrial & Labor Relations Review, 1994(1):68~85.
[37] Gruber J, Madrian B C. Employment Separation and Health Insurance Coverage[J]. Journal of Public Economics, 1997(3):349~382.
[38] 阳义南,连玉君.社会保险能降低员工辞职率吗——中国综合社会调查的双重差分模型估计[J].经济管理,2015(1):168~179.
[39] 陈乙酉,张邦辉.社会保障对农民工流动决策的影响研究——基于"推拉"理论的实证[J].农业经济问题,2018(10):132~140.
[40] 易福金,顾熀乾.歧视性新农合报销比例对农村劳动力流动的影响[J].中国农村观察,2015(3):2~15;96.
[41] Si W. Public Health Insurance and the Labor Market:Evidence from China's Urban Resident Basic Medical Insurance[J]. Health Economics,2021(2):403~431.
[42] 秦雪征,郑直.新农合对农村劳动力迁移的影响:基于全国性面板数据的分析[J].中国农村经济,2011(10):52~63;76.
[43] 贾男,马俊龙.非携带式医保对农村劳动力流动的锁定效应研究[J].管理世界,2015(9):82~91.
[44] Liu L C, Sun R J, Gu Y, et al. The Effect of China's Health Insurance on the Labor Supply of Middle-aged and Elderly Farmers[J]. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health,2020(18).
[45] 洪灏琪,宁满秀.医疗保险权益便携性是否降低了农村劳动力就业"锁定"——来自城乡居民医保统筹的准自然实验研究[J].农业技术经济,2020(11):83~95.
[46] 黄志岭.农民自我雇佣行为的决策因素及其特征分析[J].农业经济问题,2016(1):103~109.
[47] 汪润泉,周德水.农民工在城市间"用脚投票"能否实现高质量就业——基于流动人口监测调查数据的分析[J].山西财经大学学报,2021(12):42~54.
[48] 田北海,马艳茹.文化距离、地域认同、社会资本与回流农民的文化再适应[J].华中农业大学学报(社会科学版),2021(5):98~109;195~196.